Standard Ebooks

Should Peter Pan’s True Literary Heroine Be Left in the Past?

The story of Peter Pan, originally titled Peter and Wendy, is one that most people today know a little bit about even if they haven’t read the book: the figures of the boy who never grows up, the girl who grew up too fast, and the jealous pixie trying to get between them have become deeply ingrained in our collective consciousness. There’s a playful innocence to the story that has helped it endure, obscuring the more serious underlying themes of mortality, freedom, and responsibility.

In the novel, J. M. Barrie leans into one of the great tools of literature: juxtaposition. Wendy Darling’s polished, privileged life in pre-war London is as far removed as can be from the wild abandon of Peter Pan and his Lost Boys. Each is alien to the other, an intriguing grotesquery that jars against their understanding of what life should be. And it’s in this juxtaposition that the secondary character Tiger Lily emerges.

When examining the Native American characters in Barrie’s work, it’s important to understand what he was using them to achieve. Peter and Wendy was a children’s adventure story, written for and from the perspective of little boys. Barrie’s audience wanted to read about skirmishes with pirates and battles with wild red Indians, set against a Treasure Island-style backdrop.

About fifty years prior to Peter and Wendy, the American poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow published his narrative epic The Song of Hiawatha. This poem, more than any other literary work, cemented the “noble savage” in Native American dress as a stock character. The Song heralded a new fascination with Indigenous culture, with many writers going on to emulate Longfellow’s use of a fictionalizing lens on these traditional stories.

J. M. Barrie must have been inspired by the work of Longfellow and his creative descendents. When Barrie created the character Tiger Lily and her father, Great Big Little Panther, he was shaping his narrative around this already-ficionalized interpretation.

The problem, of course, was that neither Barrie had ever met a real Indiginous person (or, for that matter, a pirate). He was viewing them through the same lens as the other extraordinary creatures that populated Neverland. In this sense, Tiger Lily’s tribe, the Piccaninny, is less based on real-world identities than it is a speculative element of a magical world. But in spite of this spiritual disconnect, the character of Tiger Lily was an immediate hit.

Tiger Lily, the foil character to Wendy, the female lead, is described as “a princess in her own right. The most beautiful of dusky Dianas and the belle of the Piccaninnies, coquettish, cold and amorous by turns.” As the chief’s daughter, she’s afforded a certain amount of power and reverence in her community. While Wendy comes from a wealthy background where she was put on the track of “ladyship” by her oppressive family, Tiger Lily represents womanhood’s wilder nature.

Barrie has been criticized by today’s scholars for his portrayal of Indiginous culture. But, Tiger Lily was actually quite progressive for 1911, the year Peter and Wendy was published. She was a strong woman who repeatedly turned down suitors, determined to forge her own path. She leads her warriors into the woods, and is described as a deadly fighter. When Tiger Lily is ultimately captured by the enemy, Barrie writes “she was the daughter of a chief, she must die as a chief’s daughter, and not a whimper was to come from her.”

Juxtaposed with Wendy, a sheltered figure teetering on the precipice between childhood and adulthood, Tiger Lily goes against everything young women of the era are taught to be. In doing so, she gave female readers a different hero to look up to. These readers saw that traits like strength, courage, and autonomy—traditionally male values—were possible for them, too.

However, it’s impossible to ignore that while Wendy and her brothers were a metonym for the ordinary human world, Tiger Lily was presented as a foreign, mystical figure deeply tied to a magical landscape. As Adrienne Keene, an instructor, activist, and member of the Cherokee Nation points out, “No matter how authentic and nuanced and perfect the portrayal of the Native people is, the bottom line is you are still placing actual Indigenous folks alongside fairies and mermaids and all of these fantasy creatures—and that’s not something that is ever going to be positive for Indigenous people today.”

Which isn’t to say that writers and filmmakers haven’t tried their best. In 2012, YA author Jodi Lynn Anderson published a retelling of Peter and Wendy from Tiger Lily’s point of view, updating the character for a modern audience. The 2015 prequel film Pan attempted to remove the Native American elements entirely, reimagining Tiger Lily’s tribe as a family of Wendy’s heritage, shaped by a child’s imagination. The 2003 and 2023 adaptations both cast Indigenous actors in the role.

The difficulty lies in the rather sizeable gulf between Barrie’s original work and an adaptation that would satisfy today’s readers. How can a story be so universally loved and yet avoid hurtful stereotypes? Contemporary writers and filmmakers need to navigate this question in order to present a version that’s both true to the story and acceptable in today’s society. There are some who argue Tiger Lily should be written out entirely, relegated to the past as a failed literary experiment.

But when light is shed on problems in a character’s past, the more positive progressive elements can often be overlooked. Tiger Lily is a positive female lead: she isn’t just a tough warrior, she also balances toughness with traditionally feminine traits like elegance and beauty, showing that all of these things can co-exist in Barrie’s readers. It doesn’t have to be one or the other.

It’s important to remember that the character is above all a work of fiction, and fiction can be whatever one needs it to be in that moment. It can be empowering, or eye-opening; it can shed light on the harm that’s been done and draw attention to the complex language and beliefs of a group of people. This mutability of the character, and the broader story, are arguably why they have survived for so long.

So, should Tiger Lily be left in the past, a remnant of a simpler time? Perhaps not—because the turn of the twentieth century wasn’t really simple at all. Over the last hundred years, Tiger Lily has acted as a nexus for important conversations, and been a role model for young girls in need of a powerful hero. One thing’s for sure: whether in the 1900s or the 2000s, Neverland or the world we know, we can always use more strong women to look up to.

Free ebooks in this article